Netflix’s ‘The Discovery’ boasts a strong premise with weak execution


In “The Discovery,” released on Netflix March 31, there’s a lot of talk about people “trying to get there,” where “there” is the newly-discovered afterlife and the “trying to” part means suicide. “Trying to get there” also describes the experience of waiting for the ending of “The Discovery,” which starts off with an intriguing premise but tepidly moves toward a convoluted ending.

Rooney Mara in “The Discovery.” (Netflix)

In this sci-fi drama/pseudo-romance from Charlie McDowell (“The One I Love”), neurologist Thomas Harbor (Robert Redford, doing some of his best work within the first five minutes of the film) has discovered that there is indeed an afterlife, some other plane of existence. However, just where that afterlife is remains a mystery, one that Harbor dedicates his life to solving.

After learning of the afterlife, millions of people “try to get there” through various suicidal means. In the two years since The Discovery, the suicide rate rises by the millions. This fact doesn’t sit well with Harbor’s son Will (Jason Segel, moping more than when Lindsay Weir’s mom accidentally broke up with Nick Andopolis), also a neurologist.

VIDEO: Muppets, ‘Freaks’ and more with Jason Segel at the Austin Film Festival

Will resents Thomas for the loss of life his research has caused. He’s on his way to visit Thomas when he meets Isla (Rooney Mara), a woman who wants nothing more than to be left alone as she tries to drown herself. Will saves her and eventually takes her in at Thomas’ isolated Gothic mansion that also houses a cult-like group of people who have been affected by suicide and help Thomas with his experiments. When Thomas finds a way to record the afterlife, Will and Isla go sleuthing to prove that the research is a fraud, and end up discovering something bigger than Thomas ever imagined.

LOS ANGELES, CA – MARCH 29: (L – R) Actor Jason Segel, director Charlie McDowell and actress Rooney Mara attend the premiere of Netflix’s “The Discovery” at the Vista Theatre on March 29, 2017 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Michael Tullberg/Getty Images)

Along the way, we meet Thomas’ other son Toby (Jesse Plemons), who seems to be having the most fun out of the entire cast, turning a minor part into a scene-stealer every chance he gets. We’re treated to a convoluted romance between Will and Isla. Tiny bits of the post-Discovery world are built by some terse dialogue exchanges (“I once gave a kid a cancer diagnosis, and she reacted like I’d given her a winning lottery ticket”; “I’d rather stick my [penis] in a wood chipper than go to another funeral”) and tight camerawork (a lingering shot of Will sitting in front of a hospital board with a suicide death ticker and a sign that says “Suicide is not the answer, stay in this life”; a sad overhead shot of an empty hospital parking lot). Speaking of the post-Discovery world, it’s foggy and dimly lit, muted shades of gray enhancing the film’s dreadful mood.

However, not much attention is given to the impact of The Discovery on other people, and even less attention is paid to the question of morality in life as it relates to belief in death. Not much examination is given to the question of whether life intrinsically means something even when faced with a possible afterlife. And while the promise of life after death has been the crux of many world religions, “The Discovery” skirts that issue with a handy bit of dialogue from Thomas: “Show me someone who relies on faith and I’ll show you someone who’s given up control over whatever it is they believe.” There could have been an interesting commentary here about the way many religions (some sects of Christianity chief among them) view this world as nothing more than a holding place until we are reunited with a Creator or punished alongside its adversary once we kick the bucket. Here, there’s no mention of religion or god because “The Discovery” isn’t about those questions. Once you see the ending, it’s actually about regrets and how we live (and die) with them.

More: Rooney Mara, Michael Fassbender, Ryan Gosling star in gorgeous ‘Song to Song,’ which has little to do with music or Austin

Minor spoilers follow for the ending of “The Discovery”:

All of the lofty questions above are cast aside in favor of the bigger mystery of what exactly Thomas is recording when he records the afterlife. When a person is put under and hooked up to the glorified MRI machine that Thomas uses, the afterlife they experience is indeed another plane of existence. It’s an alternate reality to their own life, one in which they can turn the tide on the biggest regret in their life on earth before moving on into their life in death. No heaven, no hell, no purgatory, at least not in the traditionally understood sense. Just a way to make amends and move on.

Later, when one last final twist is revealed, it feels cheap and unearned after the intentionally muddy and plodding plot. By the time the film ends, it arrives at what feels like a slower, more self-important afterlife of “Black Mirror,” “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind” and McDowell’s better, similarly high-concept “The One I Love.” By that point, you just want “The Discovery” to “get there” and be over.

‘The Discovery’

Grade: C+

Starring: Robert Redford, Jason Segel, Rooney Mara, Jesse Plemons, Mary Steenburgen, Riley Keough 

Rating: Not rated; probably would be rated “R” for language, violence, thematic material

Running time: 1 hour, 50 minutes

Theaters: Streaming right now on Netflix 


Louis Black’s Linklater doc to debut at Sundance Jan. 26

"Richard Linklater - dream is destiny"
“Richard Linklater – dream is destiny”

Austin Chronicle and SXSW co-founder, Louis Black’s début documentary “Richard Linklater – dream is destiny” will première at the Sundance Film Festival Jan. 26.

The doc, which focuses on the life and career of the Austin filmmaker, reportedly uses never-before-seen archive footage, early writings and journals from Richard Linklater, original interviews with the filmmaker, and footage of him at his home and on the set”Everybody Wants Some,” which débuts at South By Southwest Film in March.

Also look for interviews with Matthew McConaughey, Ethan Hawke, Julie Delpy, Patricia Arquette, Ellar Coltrane, Kevin Smith, and colleagues such as editor Sandra Adair, producer’s rep John Pierson, friends and family.

Austin filmmaker Don Hertzfeldt’s short “World of Tomorrow” wins Sundance Grand Jury Prize

Austin filmmaker Don Hertzfeldt‘s animated short film “World of Tomorrow” won the Sundance Film Festival’s Short Film Grand Jury Prize. It beat out 59 other sort films (animation and live action are not separated for this competition.) It premiered Jan. 22 at the fest.

A still from "World of Tomorrow"
A still from “World of Tomorrow”

This is Hertzfeldt’s second win in this category; he won in 2007 for “Everything Will Be OK.”

His 2014 couch gag for the Simpsons’ was one of the greatest in the show’s history; indeed, considering how hit-or-miss that show has been since the end of the Clinton administration, it’s probably the single coolest thing the Simpsons has aired in the 21st century.

“Results” gets results, Netflix signs the Duplass brothers and more news from Sundance

*Magnolia Pictures has picked up Austin filmmaker Andrew Bujalski’s new “Results,” with Guy Pearce, Cobie Smulders, Kevin Corrigan and Giovanni Ribisi.

Cobie Smulders and Guy Pearce in "Results"
Cobie Smulders and Guy Pearce in “Results”

The ensemble comedy — about two trainers at an Austin gym (Pearce and Smulders) whose business is thrown into chaos by a new, wealthy client (Corrigan) — premiers at Sundance tomorrow.

* Deadline reported Monday that Netflix has inked a four-picture deal with former Austinites the Duplass brothers. The deal was announced at Sundance.  Netflix will bankroll four movies produced by the duo, movies which will premier in theaters before moving to Netflix.

Duplass Brothers Productions produced the Sundance-premiering “The Overnight” for writer/director Patrick Brice with  Taylor Schilling and Adam Scott. They also worked on “The Bronze” starring Melissa Rauch, Sean Baker’s “Tangerine” and the decidedly adult animated series “Animals.”

*Alex Gibney’s HBO Films documentary “Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief ” based on Austin journalist Lawrence Wright’s amazing book of the same name, premiered Sunday at Sundance and made waves almost instantly, with Marlow Stern of the Daily Beast reporting, somewhat breathlessly, it is a scathing exposé on Scientology and makes some startling accusations about its most famous member, Tom Cruise.”

Early reviews indicate it lines up somewhat with Wright’s book, with perhaps more of an emphasis on Cruise’s relationship with the organization.

* Utah filmmaker Brad Besser’s “Beaver Trilogy Part IV,” produced by Austinites Kelly Williams, Jonathan Duffy and Don Swaynos,debuted on Jan. 23. The 84-minutye documentary concerns filmmaker Trent Harris’ singular series of films about “Groovin’ Gary,” the self-proclaimed Rich Little of Beaver, Utah. Harris first filmed the guy in 1979, then attempted to recreate the footage (sort fo).

A set of films that have to be seen to be believed, the Beaver Trilogy has become a cult classic, a password for serious film nerds. Besser dives into the mythos and unpacks the original inspiration (the original p[remiered at Sundacne in 2001. Man, I hope this thing shows up at SXSW.